Everyone knows how I'll answer this. Charlie's. But really I cried twice for him. There was when he was strung up by Ethan and Jack and Kate fought to save him. I really thought he'd gone and it was way too soon. Heartbreaking and one of the darkest things I'd seen on TV for a while; blindfolded and hanging from a tree in the jungle. I was so happy when he came around. Then came his real death that I really do think is the most beautiful and terrible TV death ever. He came to terms with what he had to do and became a true hero, sacrificing everything he'd gained on the Island. "Not Penny's boat". *Sobs*.